Council for a Livable World

Political action to reduce nuclear threats

  • Elections
    • Senate Victories
    • House Victories
    • Political Analysis
    • Who We’ve Helped Elect
  • Legislation
    • Key National Security Legislation
    • National Security Legislative Calendar
    • Legislative Achievements
  • Take Action
    • Avoiding Oppenheimer’s Nuclear Nightmare in Our Current Reality
    • Twin Threats: Climate Change and Nuclear War
    • Issues
    • Join Our Email List
    • Become a Member
  • About
    • Staff
    • Press
    • Newsletter
    • Boards & Experts
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Financials and Annual Reports
    • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Search
You are here: Home / Blog / Reckless US Senators Meddling on Iran

March 3, 2012

Reckless US Senators Meddling on Iran

Senators Graham (R-SC), Lieberman (I-Conn) and Casey (D-Pa) stand for reckless Senate action that has the effect of undermining President Obama’s diplomatic efforts and use of economic sanctions to pressure Iran from building nuclear weapons. These Senators’ actions run the real risk of giving a signal of encouragement to those Israeli officials aching to strike Iran pre-emptively. If Iran havs nuclear capabilty, it does not lead to Iran building or having a nuclear weapon according to analyses by US Intelligence officials, leading alumni of Mossad (the secret Israeli intelligence service) and the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). Nuclear capability has to be distinguished from nuclear weaponization according to all of these analysts.

Prime Minister Netanyahu’s visit to the U.S., his prospective meeting with the President, and his speech to the annual AIPAC conference, further fuel the verbal and political cauldron of hot flames that adds to our political tensions and distress. The Graham-Lieberman-Casey group really is playing with fire!

Twenty nine Senators have joined the three authors in co-sponsoring a Sense of the Senate resolution which has been referred to the Foreign Relations Committee. What is instuctive is the Senators who have resisted co-sponsoring in spite of intense political pressure to do so. Senators Levin (D-Mich), Kerry (D-Mass) Feinstein (D-Calif) and Harkin (D-Ia), the respective Chairs of Armed Services, Foreign Relations, Intelligence and Appropriations, have refused to co-sponsor. Ranking Republicans who have refused to co-sponsor include Lugar (R-Ind), Saxby (R-Ga) and Cochran (R-Miss) on the Foreign Relations, Intelligence and Appropriations committees.  These Democratic and Republican Senators, realizing the stakes involved in the issue, refuse to be pressured to cross the line between constructive action and criticism and irresponsible thrusts into a delicate situation.

The Senate resolution is reckless because it specifically opposes any diplomatic agreement that allows Iran to enrich uranium for civilian peaceful purposes. The resolution would bar Iran from developing  nuclear power as a resource much in the same way as France and other countries already have.

In addition the resolution specifically opposes containment. It presents the classic false choice: doing nothing or engage in a military solution. Containment is an active policy of preventing Iran from weaponizing its nuclear arsenal if and when it has that power. It is the opposite of doing nothing. Preventing Iran from building and posessing nuclear weapons is what drives the President’s efforts.

In important quarters voices of sanity have commented in highly critical ways of what the Graham-Lieberman-Casey efforts move us towards. Listen to these sober voices.

1. Mike Rogers (R-Mich), and House Chairman of the Intelligence Committee, says on CNN that military action presents “real problems” to U.S. security interests.

2. Meir Dagan, the retired head of Mossad, says military action “would mean regional war.” It would give Iran “the best possible reason to continue the nuclear program.”

3. Secretary Panetta goes further and says that Iran “could retaliate against the U.S.” by “sinking our ships, striking our military bases’ and therby “costing many lives.” It would “consume the Middle East in a confrontation and conflict that we would regret.”

President Obama was unambiguous on three principal points in his famous Atlantic magazine interview on March 2:

1. A nuclear armed Iran is a security threat to the Middle East and the United States.

2. US policy will not accept nuclear weapons for Iran.

3. Our diplomatic strategy and economic sanctions are working. They must be allowed time to take hold.

Leader Reid (D-Nev) and Majority Whip Durbin (D-Ill) have refused to sponsor the Senate rresolution. Minority Leader McConnell (R-Ky) and Minority Whip Kyl (R-Ariz) have acted as Reid and Durbin. I doubt that the resolution will clear the Foreign Relations Committee. But don’t put it past Graham, Lieberman and their allies to attach the resolution to another Senate bill.

If they so moved, these reckless Senators present the Democratic and Republican
leadership with the rare chance to act iin the interests of the nation and together move to table, and thereby defeat, such an effort. That would be statesmanship informed by constructive action.

David Cohen
Washington DC
March 3, 2012

Posted in: Blog

Recent Posts

  • An Early Look at the 2026 House of Representatives Elections May 29, 2025
  • An Early Look at the 2026 Senate Elections May 9, 2025
  • Shawn Rostker: ‘Quiet diplomacy is likely happening, even if the public posture is more restrained’ May 7, 2025
  • Council: Front and Center: April 21, 2025 April 21, 2025
  • Council: Front and Center: March 22, 2025 March 22, 2025
Council for a Livable World logo

820 1st Street NE, Suite LL-180
Washington, D.C. 20002
Phone: 202.543.4100

Elections

  • Meet The Candidates
  • Senate Candidates
  • House Candidates
  • Who We’ve Helped Elect

Legislation

  • Key National Security Legislation
  • National Security Legislative Calendar
  • Legislative Achievements

Take Action

  • Issues
  • Join Our Email List
  • Become a Member

About

  • History & Mission
  • Staff
  • Press
  • Newsletter
  • Boards & Experts
  • Jobs & Internships
  • Financials and Annual Reports
  • Contact Us
  • Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2025 Council for a Livable World
Privacy Policy